Granny boy hit event graphic publishers was an apology lacks sincerity _ boys and Granny | | | foreign news
CCTV broadcast the News 1+1 on December 4, 2013 knocked "Granny", there is truth, there is ... ...? Show items in the original Publisher (photographer), Lee said: "because of this thing, after all, caused her a great deal of harm, previous reports had mistakes, navigability, resulting in a media misinterpretation, reputation damage to the aunt. Down to think I did wrong, I want to apologize to her. "He said:" Lee to apologize, apologize to, should the community as a whole is welcome, but the apologies seem insincere, but also kept the excuse, considered the site, including other people misunderstand his meaning. "Full program:
(Program Guide)
Narrator:
This morning she was "intentionally blackmail" foreign nice guy China "Granny", she was a foreigner illegally driving victims was knocked to the ground.
Lee:
You don't know the facts, what you journalists are journalists?
Narrator:
From accusations of hype to the truth surfaced, she experienced the worst day of my life.
Lee:
I'm retired and now I'm 50 years old, not to do business, I now have my pension, my own "touch the porcelain"?
Narrator:
Photographers saw, to produce such exciting news? Knocked down by today's focus – "Granny", also knocked out the truth.
Lee:
I say passive, don't move, give me a call.
Moderator in his:
Hello everyone, and welcome to live of the press 1+1.
I do the news for more than 20 years, over a period of more than 20 years, doing most of the press in the State, but also abroad, for example, we have mining, but also abroad. We have earthquakes but also abroad. Our food safety problems, but also abroad. But there is still a small part of news is very, very "Chinese", say, uncle aunt fell helped does not pick up news, absolutely with Chinese characteristics. If fell off my uncle aunt helped was helped by news that China is the world's first. We take a look at for some time, just a few days ' time will have as many articles with content-related news, November 26, fell down an elderly in Jiujiang city in Jiangxi province, people help. Zhengzhou no one helped an elderly man fell on December 2. Shanghai, December 2 the hand grip of a foreign woman injured in a car accident. On December 3, an old man on the ground in Fuzhou, bus driver first get someone to testify and then humans. But fell at so many days over the society did not hold the news, this news than in Beijing, fermentation quickly became big news, but in fact it shouldn't exist, we take a look at.
Narrator:
Within a day, she mounted two successive tweets hot, first morning she had been described as a street in Beijing "blackmail" Granny foreign guys in China. Doubts began to appear in the afternoon until the evening, Police Department's evidence in order to bring her innocence. Yesterday, December 3, Lee experience of 50 years should be the wronged, the most difficult day of my life.
Lee:
I'm pissed off at this and I'm not saying anything else, what the reporter is reporter? You don't know the facts.
Narrator:
Eight pictures of rich detail, the news report said: "a northeast accent woman after a bike next to foreigners when it suddenly fell down, get off foreign boy hastened to help women, but women grabbed woman doom pull foreign guys, foreign men had to pay 1800 medicines, women just give up. "Yesterday morning, pictures and the truth on this exciting news spread rapidly, from Shenyang to Beijing for five years, is here to take care of his daughter Lee was in the news as" Auntie ", her picture was carried over accusations of her behavior has been overwhelming:" shame cannot be conducive to blackmail by the wind. Moral decline, Chinese actors. Auntie is terrible. "Comment comes from India, but. Even one company claims that: "please contact the foreign friends, our company is willing to pay 1800 for him, and rewarded its civilization is 1000 dollars. As Chinese, we can't afford to lose this one. ”
Mrs Li:
I'm calling the police, I had a green light, I have normal green.
Narrator:
But in the afternoon, a reporter visiting the scene, get a different evidence.
Witnesses:
(Subject) emotion and anger, could not say anything.
Narrator:
New evidence shows that the foreign boy seems to be poor, he Li woman in the video maker loud curses out curse words in Chinese.
Lee:
What do you have to leave and wanted to run, that foreigners will scold, scold can be harsh, and he hit me and yell at me and say I'm sorry, this is itself we have the truth in life, sorry, you hit a major, needed a hospital? He did not, two of his assailants.
Narrator:
Torment for a day, finally, let things go to clear is "safe Beijing" micro-blog. Last night, the Beijing police released surveillance video confirmed that 10:33 on that day, a car with two people on a motorcycle in Bend, collided with the woman is walking on the pavement.
Lee:
Happens to be a red light, the car has stopped, I went from Zebra green walking home, he was here, he was retrograde, a Big Bend me, he was the only one, because the rate of red light car completely stops, he came to this, I was knocked down.
Narrator:
Beijing police said a preliminary identification of the male of driving without a license, driving without licence plates for motorcycles, motorcycles the accident have been withhold on the same day, its traffic violations will be punished according to law. At this point, "the blackmailing Lady" Lee got her innocence.
Lee:
TV says I "touch the porcelain", then I would have to fire, I do business forever, I send money? I went to "touch the porcelain", and I can't afford to eat rice? I now retire at age 50, my business is not done, I now have my pension, I "touch the porcelain"?
Moderator:
This actually is a article shouldn't became news of news, because in world, are or said world, full China daily in street crashed with so hit about of thing estimated ultimately, but this article News quickly was fermentation, comes is people in recent years are in talked about put people hit pour has zhihou what the helped shouldn't helped, pointed we everyone moral and inside, because behind has a subtext, now of Chinese how such. Now how the Chinese this way, but this time met a foreigner suddenly doing multiplication, this should not be news News will quickly be magnified, but also reversed overnight. Scolding aunt one day, next day cursing at young men, is now concentrated in scolding the media, including the eldest sister, but in fact is not a journalist? Nor, if you called him a photograph provided, seems to be more accurate. We see with pictures, and pictures look foreign boy was helpless, live recorded. Sometimes we say that there is truth, not at all, look at what angle and moment. We see the last guy is pitiful. Now we'll take a look at the photographer with map text, too resistant to ponder, "northeastern accent of a woman after a bike next to a foreigner suddenly fell down immediately afford to limp on the ground. Foreign guys to get off quickly ", with a young man this place is good and in a foreign country, using big sister this block a bit miserable," the whole woman grabbed, who was hit by a foreigner was injured in the legs to walk, require that foreigners are responsible for. Foreign men were alarmed, but women down to stall. Walking woman uninjured in the dispute ", it's all right," but also doom ferret out foreign boy to ride to hang on, causing traffic jams for more than an hour at the scene of the accident, the woman came many times twitching, insisting foreign boy was knocked down, and put them in charge. Foreign boy is anxious to cry. "What a great kid. "After the police rushed to the scene, and he has also been followed. The woman was not injured. " OK, that said, actually in the text quite tendentious, directly led to this misunderstanding occurred, so we look at the surveys, you saw aunt "blackmail" foreigner press what is your first reaction? To be true, 59.8%, not only the figure, there is actually biased text and very clear. Considered to be false only 8.49%. Hard to say, need to investigate and look at 31.71%. I hope that this rapid data growth. Well, think of what we see reference to elderly and fell, 53.39% people think it's blackmail. Straight news and text caters to speculation and legend. But today the photographer Lee apologized.
A graphic originally posted by Lee (photographer):
Because of this, after all, to give her has caused a lot of damage, previous reports had mistakes, navigability, resulting in a media misinterpretation, reputation damage to the aunt. Down to think I did wrong, I want to apologize to her.
Narrator:
This afternoon, the news picture original photographer Lee talk to Lee to apologize to in the event of a crash, and major websites, "Granny correct foreigner" news have also been deleted. Event appears to be quietly to calm, but we still have to ask, the foreigner hit under the dissemination of facts in a variety of ways, have become "Lady lie"? Yang Feng, a newspaper reporter in Beijing yesterday, at around nine o'clock in the morning, he saw the "Granny correct foreigner" news of the initial release.
Yang Feng:
Granny after a ride when the boy suddenly fell down, boy go up Granny, Granny or not, requires small group is responsible. We suspect should not have been so simple, we just wanted to see what no bump, lie no lie.
Narrator:
Yang Feng as a news source, is the graphic originally posted by Lee when Lee accidentally witnessed the incident. So, how he sees the scene it?
Lee:
Aunt to the scene was the first time I saw this lying on the ground, the young man to stop, this is what I saw.
Reporter:
But why do you conclude that she is true and correct at the time the boy, then?
Lee:
The correct saying is a little exaggerated, saying I don't want blackmail, probably a day-to-day language.
Narrator:
Been hit after Lee went to the hospital to check, Lee has issued a new text, in this version, Lee suddenly fell into a "minor scuffing was" as objective a number, but the writing topic is "foreign dude helped aunt fell badly in Beijing was anxious cries blackmail."
Reporter:
Sent two text description before and after you, right?
Lee:
At the beginning of most, there is a time difference, later identified, they fill up.
Reporter:
I think your story is "foreign dude was anxious cries", this is your scene to see it?
Lee:
This aside from the fact that, right. I personally feel he is in orbit, and one nasty, inevitable, that doesn't mean cry or something.
Narrator:
However, regardless of which version, graphics and original publisher of Lee's statement last objective, which has also led to the media yesterday to follow up the matter.
Yang Feng:
Then we on to interview, to scene found witnesses, then very skillfully and found has Granny, and found has that foreigners, and found has that photo of, last three party claims out zhihou, found things fundamental not like online said of as, witnesses said Granny from start to finish no in scene disputed of process in the mention had "I to compensation" such of words, Granny said of up of is I to alarm, I to protection scene.
Narrator:
Yang Feng yesterday contacted Lee for his graphic report called into question the objectivity expression, but at the time of Lee, it still is the expression of an emotion.
Yang Feng:
He insisted he had no problems when he made this figure in whipping Granny this ugly, trying to convey about justice.
Moderator:
Lee to apologize, apologize to, should the community as a whole is welcome, but the apologies seem insincere, but also kept the excuse, considered the site, including other people misunderstand his meaning. But I don't know to this day at the moment, Lee will have a deep introspection, when this happens to you again in the future, would you do it? And Lee is not just LEE himself, as well as every one of us. In the middle of the chain, it seems to us that a worried, the Publisher to make a certain feel in advance, then rush release, and then each of us anxious to believe, followed by worried anger right away, and then rush to criticize. Then after the rioting, is no longer used as foreign boy had problems, we are anxious to get scolding a child. The Chinese right now, why the hurry? Many of our truth has disappeared, probably with this in a hurry are closely related. Of course, we should also reflect on its own. But in this case the whole process, like a mirror of contemporary China, and China today and every one of us. Ask an expert, about how he used to look. Beijing University Professor Zhang Yiwu. Hello, Professor.
Zhang Yi Wu:
How do you do.
Moderator:
You must be concerned about this thing from your mind, what do you think this mirror shine on us?
Zhang Yi Wu of Peking University Professor:
I think we of comments are is in facts zhiqian, everyone are is regardless of is Lee a also is we of media, also is we of public, we of micro-Bo inside since media are is such, is comments to has facts zhiqian, in no figure out Chu facts zhiqian, everyone are has preconceptions, preconceptions is after has recently a time media has been in rendering of "touch porcelain", Granny framed good or pulled live has good, such of situation into has very general pan of discourse, in community widely of diffuse. This situation, if it happened in this case is disputed, are generally two situations are true, was, in fact, exist in two cases, one is touching, wanting to stay, not to be touched, helpful, but trying to correct people. This two species situation actually in community are exists, but another a situation is, hit has people wanted to Lai this situation often in moral Shang is not impact like correct people so strongly, so we often on this concern degrees no so big, instead is most strongly of, into social in very anxiety of phenomenon, everyone are desperately of attacked this thing, last leads to black dragon of case, everyone last found put themselves drying in these.
Moderator:
Professor, do you think such a thing, and overnight turnaround happens, will we change? China ourselves to be present in everyone's heart for the better a little bit?
Zhang Yi Wu:
I think the first and most critical is for now don't worry, will need a findings of fact, is the fact that what is going on. We in attacked, in expression themselves of outrage, expression themselves moral height of front first understanding facts, this is most important of, regardless of is mainstream of media also is we of since media, also is we General of public, I think this is most important of, facts situation once clear has, actually this problem on settlement has, this authority sector later quickly finds, "peace Beijing" of micro-Bo also published has on this problem of finds, such yihou, this situation and occurred has big of reversed, Now, I think we first of all is to find out the facts. 2nd, facts actually requires a certain amount of time, room before they are published, even if it is very easy to post a message, be sure to take this thing, since there is no clear, will make this fact clear. I think a lot of it right now is the lack of adequate recognition and understanding of the facts, has had a great deal of moral indignation and moral judgments. Now, we need further identified a clear understanding of the facts, this is the crux of the problem.
Moderator:
Each of us has nothing to do with it, we are just angry and bystanders, but also will have to reflect on it?
Zhang Yi Wu:
Yes, before we make statements, facts should be half a step slow to judge, before doing your own moral judgments, half a step slow, and this is very important, a little delayed in time so that after the facts became clear, we'll further reflection, analysis, this is more important. At the same time, before we save lives, I now feel the need for a get to know each other, and after the collision frame, everyone on the fact that there is a full certification, which is the basis of social need critical issues.
Moderator:
Thank you very much Professor bring us interpretation. Indeed, remind us of the things as they are today, a lot of things you can't rush, don't worry angry, sometimes do not worry even touched, until real facts in front of us, and then to release the emotion, outrage, including comments, in fact, for this community to maintain an environment that gives us pleasure, it may be more beneficial. Of course, at this point, I would also like to stress that I like this news, I really don't like the news, but after such changes have taken place, starting to like it, like it does? It will reminded we future not so worried immediately produces reaction, like a investigation on proved has this ending, you again see touch porcelain or blackmail news first reaction is what, think is really of 43.01%, think is fake of 5.71%, bad said, needs again see investigation results has reached has 51.28%, this is this article news in big reversed facts of while, also in reminded we each personal should reflection about themselves.
Well, speaking of which, I finally on this matter there is a few words, in fact, whether the sister is being hit, or an entire community, including every one of us, acting as appropriate after forgiving, not apologizes. Of course, man does not, and forgiving that I say is hypothetical, the compensation must be compensated, without a license should be punished by law, but to exalt and give a lot of spit saliva or society, we should turn themselves into the contemporary "Boxer". In fact this young man, foreign guy he should reflect on, but should not be excessive, because he was a foreigner, they rose to "a member of the eight-power allied forces," such a concept, there is such a message. Open Chinese anger, men, women, foreigners, people, adults, children, equality is a sign of progress.
Next we're concerned about the same thing happen in Hong Kong, many Hong Kong people in the Mainland guessing and confused, even said to be suspected, even a bit angry that there is such a weird news.
Narrator:
"Granny correct foreigners" only experienced a flip in a day, media attention and reflection continues today, in Hong Kong, similar reflection appears to be carried out, because in the last week, Hong Kong also staged other banjun dramas. Photos in this lively cute of children called Kay love, only half age big, on in last month 23rd, she of mother alarm said, she in day pushed with baby car daughter out walking Shi, met Shang a male a female asked road, which one more than 40 age, wearing black clothing, and blue jeans, and said Guangdong words accent of mainland woman to she asked road, and on in she enthusiastic of refers to finished road Hou, is found baby car in of Kay love missing has. Hong Kong baby theft cases rapidly cause us concern, Hong Kong police force not only carried out a large number of police investigations, according to Kay mother's accounts, issued a warrant against middle-aged women from the Mainland, and Hong Kong Customs also stepped up vigilance of the port guard, in addition to this, the night of the incident, there are zealous groups in Hong Kong established on the net to get the children, at least 55,000 people were involved. Mother warning claimed to be women in the Interior, some Hong Kong media have reported that pointed in the direction of the Mainland, said stealing gangs have killed children to Hong Kong from the Mainland. Hong Kong Internet users are also missing from the infant's attention shifted to the Mainland on the accused people. Hong Kong's Secretary for security, Mr Lai Tung-Kwok said that seven cases were suspected of turning over the past decade baby, do not involve the mainland people, the case involving mainland baby trafficking gang of unlikely, but he still cannot eliminate the doubts of some parents.
People:
Worry that I will watch for your child, and where he goes I'll follow.
People:
Worry, so two men bring her out, a person can't take.
Narrator:
But in the event after nine days of fermentation, the Hong Kong Police through a meticulous investigation, has finally discovered the whereabouts of Kat, but she is no longer living and the murderer is her mother. On December 2, Kat's mother admits, on the 17th of last month after waking up in the morning and found Kat, sudden death, kill suspected was covered with a quilt over and choking, followed her daughter's body hidden in a violin case, and litter. Due to the difficulty to tell loved ones, fictional child was stolen from the Mainland lies. Learns the sensational baby was the so-called decoy party trafficking incidents in the Mainland of Hong Kong are completely erroneous. Sue broke the case, said the mother had been arrested by police, and yesterday issued new paper reported that "innocent people were wrongly accused of the Mainland, Hong Kong people repeated insinuations, before they have to establish the truth, wild accusations mainland visitors, cold-blooded terror Hong Kong people, should apologize to the Mainland. ”
Moderator:
Why have these two things in our part of the press 1+1 say? Social psychology behind it is exactly the same, it takes advantage of the people's trust, and then made a reverse news, which is that we all think of aunt must have been correct a foreigner, because such a thing is simply too much. So, today we will know the truth, is not the case, is this foreign young man riding a motorcycle hit her. Occurred in Hong Kong and it is also why this mother you should think as long as that is the mainland people, some media in Hong Kong, including a lot of people to believe, and if that's the case, until the truth came out, mainland people overall, including me, each of us suspected crisis lifted. End, still this thing against Beijing's Xinhua News Agency, Xinhua, said, "I don't know your name, to North-Eastern accent ladies say sorry to you from the injured into a" touch the porcelain ", and wronged. Microblogging journalists and netizens are gatekeepers, you need to provide the truth and rational thinking, no man is an island in the Internet era, no Maniang, piled on the wrong turn, we all owe her an apology. "Like Hong Kong media say, also owes the mainland people know I'm sorry. Of course, Lee, including every one of us should be careful to think, when it comes to this kind of thing in the future, are we going to do? We are also first day scolding aunt, and the next day called laowai, and then went on to scold the media? Wonder is the beginning of progress.
(Edit: SN094) December 04, 2013(小伙撞大妈事件图文发布者被指道歉缺少诚意|大妈|小伙|外国_新闻资讯
央视《新闻1+1》2013年12月4日播出《撞倒的有“大妈”，有真相，还有……？》节目中图文最初发布者(摄影师)李某说：“因为这个事毕竟给她造成了很大的伤害，之前的报道也有失误，有一点导向性，造成了媒体误读，让大妈受到了名誉上的损害。静下心来想我确实不对，我要跟她道歉一下。”主持人说：“李某道歉了，道歉是对的，应该整个这个社会都是欢迎，但是道歉似乎显得不够诚恳，而且还在不停的辩解，认为是网站，包括别人在误解他的意思。”节目实录：
(节目导视)
解说：
上午她是“故意讹诈”外国好小伙的中国“大妈”，晚上她是一个被违章驾车的老外撞倒在地的受害者。
李女士：
你不了解事实，你这个记者是什么记者？
解说：
从铺天盖地的指责到真相浮出水面，她经历了人生里最难过的一天。
李女士：
我现在我50岁退休了，生意不做了，我现在还有退休金，我自己“碰瓷”吗？
解说：
摄影师看到了什么，生产出了如此刺激的新闻？今日关注——撞倒了“大妈”，也撞倒了真相。
李女士：
我说被动，别动，给我打电话报警。
主持人 白岩松：
您好观众朋友，欢迎收看正在直播的《新闻1+1》。
我做新闻也20多年了，在这20多年的时间里，做的绝大多数的新闻中国有，国外也有，比如说咱们这儿有矿难，国外也有。咱们这儿有地震，国外也有。咱这有食品安全的问题，国外也有。但是还是有少部分的新闻可真是特别特别的“中国”，比如说大爷大妈摔倒了扶不扶起来成为新闻，绝对有中国特色。如果说大爷大妈摔倒了扶不扶这样的新闻，中国是世界第一。我们看一下近一段日子，仅仅几天时间里就有多少条与这样的内容有关的新闻，11月26日，江西九江市区一名老人摔倒，路人出手相助。12月2号郑州一名老人倒地无人扶。12月2日，上海一名外国女子紧握车祸伤者的手。12月3日，福州一老人倒地，公交司机先找人作证再扶人。但是这么多几天时间里发生了摔倒了扶不扶这样的新闻，都不如在北京发生的这起新闻，迅速发酵成了超级大新闻，但其实它是不该存在的，我们来看一看。
解说：
一天内，她连续两次登上微博热门排行榜，先是早上她被人描述成是一个在北京街头“讹诈”外国小伙的中国大妈。到了下午开始出现了疑点，直到晚上，公安部门的证据才彻底还了她清白。昨天，12月3日，50岁的李女士经历的应该是人生中最委屈、最难受的一天。
李女士：
我就生这个气，我不是说生别的，这个记者是什么记者？你不了解事实。
解说：
现场的八张图片细节描写丰富，新闻报道说：“一名东北口音女子在经过一个骑车老外旁边时突然摔倒，外国小伙儿下车急忙搀扶女子，却被女子一把揪住，女子死命撕扯外国小伙，外国小伙不得不己付1800元药费，女子方才作罢。”昨天一大早，这条有图有真相的刺激性新闻被迅速传播，从沈阳来北京已经五年，来京照顾女儿的李女士在新闻中被称为“大妈”，她的照片被大家转来转去，她的行为也遭到铺天盖地的指责：“丢人，不能助长讹诈之风。道德滑坡，中国好演员。大妈可怕。”评论汹涌而来。甚至有一家公司对外宣称：“请联系这位外国朋友，我公司愿替他赔偿1800元，并奖励其文明行为1000元。因为作为中国人，我们丢不起这个人。”
李女士：
我要报警，我过绿灯，我正常过绿灯。
解说：
但是到了下午，有记者前往事发现场，拿到了不一样的证据。
目击者：
(当事人)激动，气愤，也说不出什么话来。
解说：
新证据显示，这个外国小伙儿似乎也不善，视频中他对着李女师大声用中文骂着脏话。
李女士：
你们就要走呢，想跑，那老外就骂人，骂的可难听，他又撞我，又骂我，你说对不起，这是本身我们做人的道理，对不起，你撞得严重不，需要上医院吗？他反而没有，他俩特凶。
解说：
煎熬了一天，最后让事情走向清晰的是“平安北京”的微博。昨晚，北京警方发布监控录像，证实在当日10时33分，一辆载有两人的摩托车在拐弯时，与正在行人道上行走的女子相撞。
李女士：
正好是红灯，车都停了，我就从斑马线绿灯往家走，他是从那边过来，他是逆行的，一个大弯就奔我来，就他一个车，因为红率灯车全停了嘛，他就过来一下就给我撞倒。
解说：
北京警方表示，初步查明该外籍男子系无证驾驶，所驾摩托车无牌照，已于当日暂扣了肇事摩托车，其交通违法行为将依法处罚。至此，“讹诈大妈”李女士才得到了清白。
李女士：
电视说我“碰瓷”，当时我火就来了，我做一辈子生意，我差钱吗？我去“碰瓷”，我还吃不起饭？我现在50岁退休了，我生意不做了，我现在还有退休金，我至于“碰瓷”吗？
主持人：
这其实是一条不该成为新闻的新闻，因为在全世界，都要不说全世界，全中国每天在街上咣当这么撞一下的事估计少不了，但是这条新闻迅速被发酵，一来是人们近几年都在谈论把人撞倒了之后到底该扶不该扶，直指我们每个人道德和内心，因为背后有一个潜台词，现在的中国人怎么这样。结果现在的中国人怎么这样，偏偏这回遇到了一个老外，这一下子就做了乘法了，这件不该成为新闻的新闻就迅速被放大，而且还出现了一夜之间这样的逆转。头一天人们在骂大妈，第二天在骂小伙子，现在集中在骂媒体，包括刚才这位大姐，但是其实到底是不是一个记者呢？其实也不一定，如果叫他一个摄影图片的提供者，似乎更加准确。我们来看这样一些提供的图片，图片看上去外国的小伙子很无奈，现场的情况记录下来。有的时候我们说有图有真相，不一定，看在哪个角度和哪个瞬间。我们看到最后小伙子很惨。现在我们再来看看摄影师的配图文字，太耐琢磨了，“一个东北口音女子在经过一个骑车老外旁边的时候突然摔倒，随即瘫软倒地不起。外国小伙下车急忙”，用在外国小伙子这儿全是好词，用到大姐这块都有点惨，“全被女子一把揪住，自称被老外撞到腿部受伤无法行走，需要该老外负责。外国小伙大惊失色，却被女子死死拖住。在争执中女子行走无恙”，没事，“可是还死命揪扯外国小伙儿，骑车不撒手，事故造成现场交通拥堵一个多小时，女子多次瘫软抽搐，坚称被外国小伙儿撞倒，并让其负责。外国小伙儿被急哭。”多好的小孩儿。“后来警方赶到了现场，然后他还一直在跟着。该女子并未受伤”等等。好了，说到这儿，其实在文字当中相当有倾向性，直接导致人们会产生这样的误读，所以我们看看调查，您当时看到大妈“讹诈”老外的新闻第一反应是什么？认为是真的，59.8%，不仅有图，还有刚才其实有偏向性的文字，而且非常明显。认为是假的只有8.49%。不好说，需要再看看调查的31.71%。真希望将来这个数据快速增长。好了，我们再来看提到老人和摔倒联想到什么，53.39%的人认为是讹诈。直接这样的新闻和文字迎合了人们的猜测和联想。但是今天这位摄影师李某道歉了。
李某 图文最初发布者(摄影师)：
因为这个事毕竟给她造成了很大的伤害，之前的报道也有失误，有一点导向性，造成了媒体误读，让大妈受到了名誉上的损害。静下心来想我确实不对，我要跟她道歉一下。
解说：
今天下午，新闻图片最初的拍摄者李某开口向事件中的被撞者李女士道歉，而各大网站上，“大妈讹老外”的新闻也早已被删除。事件看似正静静平息，但我们依然要问，老外撞人的事实怎么就在各种途径的传播下，变成了“大妈讹人”？杨锋，北京某报社的记者，昨天上午九点多，他就看到了这条“大妈讹老外”新闻的最初版本。
杨锋：
大妈在经过一个骑车小伙时突然摔倒，小伙儿去扶起大妈，大妈不愿意，要求小伙负责。当时我们就怀疑事情应该没有那么简单，我们就想搞清楚到底撞没撞，到底讹没讹。
解说：
杨锋看到的这一版新闻源头，正是图文最初的发布者李某，这时的李某只是偶然目睹了这一事件。那么，他看到的现场究竟是怎样的呢？
李某：
到现场第一时间我看见的是这个阿姨躺在地上，这个小伙子去扶，这是我看见的。
记者：
但当时您为什么就断定她是在讹这个小伙儿呢？
李某：
这个讹说的有点夸张了吧，说讹诈不是我的本意，可能就是一个日常化的语言吧。
解说：
而在被撞者李女士前往医院检查后，李某又发布了一则新的文字，在这一版本中，李女士突然摔倒的表述变成了“遭到轻微碰擦”，似乎客观了许多，但文字的题目却是“外国帅哥北京扶摔倒大娘惨被讹诈急哭”。
记者：
你前后发了两版文字说明是吧？
李某：
最开始的时候，有一个时间差，后来确定了，就补上去了。
记者：
我看您报道写的是“外国帅哥被急哭”，这是您在现场看到的吗？
李：
这个先不说了吧。我个人觉得他是在眼眶中打转，人急了，难免的，这个也不是说痛哭流涕什么的。
解说：
但无论前后哪版，图文最初的发布者李某的表述都难言客观，而这也引发了媒体在昨天纷纷跟进此事。
杨锋：
然后我们就去采访，去现场找到目击者，然后非常巧又找到了大妈，又找了那个老外，又找到了那个拍照的，最后三方说法出来之后，发现事情根本不像网上说的那样，目击者说大妈从头至尾没有在现场争执的过程中提过“我要赔偿”这样的字眼，大妈说的最多的是我要报警，我要保护现场。
解说：
昨天杨锋曾联系李某对他的图文报道的客观性表达质疑，但当时的李某表达的仍是这样一种情绪。
杨锋：
他坚持认为他没有问题，他当时发这个图是为了鞭笞一下大妈的这种丑恶，想传达一下正义。
主持人：
李某道歉了，道歉是对的，应该整个这个社会都是欢迎，但是道歉似乎显得不够诚恳，而且还在不停的辩解，认为是网站，包括别人在误解他的意思。但是我不知道到今天此时此刻，李某会不会有一种深深的反省，今后你再遇到这种情况的时候会怎么做呢？而且李某不仅仅是李某本人，也包括我们每一个人。在整个链条当中，我们似乎看到了一种着急，发布者提前去设定某种感受，然后着急的发布，然后我们每一个人着急的相信，接下来马上就着急的愤怒，然后着急的去骂。然后一变天之后，不再是大妈，变成外国小伙儿有问题，我们又着急的赶紧骂小孩儿。中国人此时此刻怎么这么着急呢？我们很多真相之所以消失，恐怕也与这种着急紧密相关。当然，我们每个人也应该反省自己。不过在这个事情整个过程当中，像一面镜子照出了当下的中国，也照出了当下中国的我们每一个人。请教一位专家，他怎么去看。北京大学张颐武教授。张教授您好。
张颐武：
您好。
主持人：
这件事情你一定在关注，从您的心目当中，您觉得这面镜子照到了我们什么？
张颐武 北京大学教授：
我觉得咱们的评论都是在事实之前，大家都是不论是李某还是我们的媒体，还是我们的公众，我们的微博里边自媒体都是这样，就是评论到了事实之前，在没有弄清楚事实之前，大家都有先入之见，先入之见是经过了最近一段时间媒体一直在渲染的“碰瓷”，大妈诬陷好人或者拉住了好人，这样的情况变成了非常普泛的话语，在社会上广泛的弥漫。其实这个情况，如果是两个人在这个情况下发生争执，一般是两种情况都存在，在事实上也是两种情况都存在，一个是碰了，想赖，一个是说没碰，热心助人，但是这边想讹人。这两种情况其实在社会上都存在，但是另一种情况就是，撞了人想赖这种情况往往在道德上并不是冲击力像讹人那么强烈，所以我们往往对这个关注度没有那么大，反而是最强烈的，变成社会里非常焦虑的现象，大家都拼命的抨击这个事，最后引出来乌龙的案子，大家最后发现把自己晾在这些。
主持人：
张教授，您觉得这样的事情，而且一夜之间发生了大逆转，会让我们改变吗？会当下的中国我们自己每个人的内心变得更好一点吗？
张颐武：
我想首先最关键的是我们现在先别着急，需要一个对事实的认定，就是事实究竟是怎么回事。我们在抨击，在表达自己的义愤，表达自己道德高度的前面先了解事实，这是最重要的，无论是主流的媒体还是我们的自媒体，还是我们一般的公众，我觉得这个是最重要的，事实情况一旦清晰了，其实这个问题就解决了，这次权威部门后来迅速认定，“平安北京”的微博也发表了关于这个问题的认定，这样以后，这个情况又发生了大的逆转，现在我是觉得我们首先一点就是先弄清事实。第二点，实际上弄清事实就需要有一定的时间，在发布之前要留有余地，即使是非常着急要发布消息，一定要把这个事情，既然没有弄清楚，就要把这个事实先弄清楚。我现在觉得很多这方面就是缺少对事实充分的认定和了解，产生了很大的道德上的义愤，道德上的判断。现在需要的，大家需要对事实进一步认清了解，这是最核心的问题。
主持人：
是否我们每一个人好像与此事无关，我们只是愤怒者和旁观者，但是也要有所反省呢？
张颐武：
对，我们在发表议论之前，应该对事实缓半步做判断，做自己的道德上的判断之前，先缓半步，这是非常重要的，时间上有一点点延后，使得事实逐渐清晰化以后，我们再做进一步的思考、分析，这个比较重要。同时，我们在救人之前，我现在觉得也需要有一个让大家互相之间，在碰撞诬陷以后，大家对事实有一个充分的认证，这是社会需要有的基础关键的问题。
主持人：
非常感谢张教授给我们带来的解读。的确，今天这样的事情在提醒我们，很多事情真不能那么着急，不要着急愤怒，甚至有的时候也不要着急感动，等到真正的事实呈现在我们面前的时候，再去释放相关的情绪、义愤，包括评论，其实对这个社会保持一种更加让我们愉悦的环境，可能更有好处。当然，说到这里的时候，我还想强调我喜欢这条新闻，其实我非常不喜欢这条新闻，但是发生了这种变化之后，开始喜欢它，喜欢它什么呢？它会提醒我们今后不那么着急立即产生反应，比如说一个调查就证明了这个结局，您再看到碰瓷或者讹诈新闻第一反应是什么，认为是真的43.01%，认为是假的5.71%，不好说，需要再看看调查结果已经达到了51.28%，这就是这条新闻在大逆转事实的同时，也在提醒我们每一个人应该反省一下自己。
好了，说到这儿，最后针对这个事情还有几句话，其实不管是这位被撞的大姐，还是整个社会，包括我们每一个人，得理之后也可以适当的饶人，不能得理不饶人。当然，大姐不会，我说的这种得理要饶人是有前提的，该赔偿的必须赔偿，没有驾照法律应该给予惩处，但是再去拔高，给予很多吐沫或者社会的口水，我们该把自己变成当代的“义和团”了。其实这个小伙子，外国的小伙子他也应该去反省，但是不应该被过度，因为他是一个外国人，就上升到了“八国联军一份子”这样的概念，有这样的留言。其实开放的中国需要心平气和的面对男人、女人、外国人、中国人、大人、小孩，平等就是一种进步。
接下来我们要关注同样的一件事情，在香港发生的，也是利用很多香港人对内地人的猜测和不解，甚至说是怀疑，甚至有一点愤怒，于是出现了这样一条怪怪的新闻。
解说：
“大妈讹老外”仅用一天就经历了大反转，今天媒体的关注和反思还在继续，而在香港，类似的反思似乎也在进行，因为在前些天香港也上演了另一出反转剧。照片里这个活泼可爱的孩子叫凯情，只有半岁大，就在上个月23日，她的母亲报警称，她在前一天推着婴儿车带女儿外出散步时，遇上一男一女问路，其中一名40多岁，穿黑衣、蓝色牛仔裤、说广东话乡音的内地女子向她问路，而就在她热心的指完路后，却发现婴儿车里的凯情不见了。一时间香港婴儿偷窃案迅速引发大家的关注，香港警方不但出动了大批警力开展调查，还根据凯情母亲的陈述，发布了针对内地中年妇女的通缉令，并且香港海关也在口岸加强了警惕防范，除此之外，就在事发当晚，还有热心港人在网上建立找回孩子的群组，至少有5.5万人参与其中。由于母亲报警声称是内地妇女所为，一些香港的媒体也将报道的方向指向了内地，称内地偷孩子的团伙已经杀到香港了。一些香港网友也从对婴儿丢失的关注转移到对内地人的指责上。虽然香港保安局局长黎栋国曾表示，过去十年共有七宗涉嫌拐婴案，都不涉及内地人，此案涉及内地婴儿拐卖团伙的可能性极微，但他的说法仍无法消除一些父母的疑虑。
市民：
会担心，我之后会多注意看孩子，他去哪里我都会跟着。
市民：
比较担心，所以要两个人带她出来，一个人不敢带。
解说：
然而就在事件发酵了九天后，香港警方通过缜密侦查，终于发现了小凯情的下落，但她已经不在人世，而凶手正是她的母亲。12月2日，小凯情的母亲承认，在上个月17日早上睡醒后就发现小凯情猝死，怀疑是被被子盖过头而窒息送命，随后她将女儿尸体藏于小提琴琴盒，并当垃圾丢弃。由于难以向亲人交待，才虚构了孩子被内地人盗走的谎言。真相大白，耸人听闻的香港婴儿被所谓内地拐子党拐卖事件纯属子虚乌有。随着案件的告破，这位母亲已被警方拘捕，而香港新报在昨天却发出这样的报道，“内地人无辜被冤枉，港人多番含沙射影，在未查明真相前，就胡乱指责内地客，冷血恐怖的港人，应该给内地人道歉。”
主持人：
为什么把这两件事情放在我们这一期《新闻1+1》里说呢？它背后的社会心理是完全一致的，它都是利用了人们的相信，然后去制造了一种其实是反向的新闻，前者利用的是人们都觉得大妈一定是在讹老外，因为这样的事简直太多了。于是，今天我们才知道真相，原来不是这样，是这个外国小伙子骑摩托的确撞到了她。而发生在香港这件事情也同样是如此，这个母亲先想好了只要说是内地人，一定香港的媒体，包括很多人都去相信，果真事实如此，直到真相出来，内地人整体，包括我在内，我们每一个人在内被怀疑的危机才解除。最后结束，还是用针对北京的这件事的新华社的新华网事上说的，“不知道你的名字，要向东北口音的女士说声对不起，你从受伤者变成了“碰瓷”者，受委屈了。微博年代记者和网友都是把关人，需要提供真相，理性思考，网络时代没有人是一座孤岛，不能骂娘，一拥而上认错事不关己，我们都欠她一声对不起。”就像香港媒体说的，也欠内地人一声对不起。当然，李某，包括我们每一个人也应该仔细的去思考，今后再遇到这种事情的时候，我们该怎么样呢？我们是不是也是头一天骂大妈，第二天骂老外，然后接着骂媒体？反省自己是进步的开始。
（编辑：SN094）2013年12月04日23:57)